MY INTERPRETATION OF THE FIRST AMENDMENT

-



 Some people are calling my recent post on Facebook regarding the censorship of foul language as being a violation of their 1st Amendment rights. In my opinion people do not have a proper understanding of what the 1st Amendment really means. My job as a mall security officer requires me to enforce mall rules regarding the language that is written on tee shirts and other clothing. For example people are not allowed to wear a tee shirt with the F word or any other profane words on them. You can buy these shirts and hats all day long in Spencers but you can't wear them out of the store. If you are a parent shopping with your children and you prefer not to shop at Spencers because, you don't want your children seeing those words, you should not have to encounter them in the common area of the mall. Our mall policy is that we want to keep a family friendly environment. This is why mall management enforces a dress code. They can do that because the mall is private property. 

 Private property rights will generally always prevail in court. I know because I have been called to court several times regarding private property rights vs.1st Amendment rights. Where the 1st Amendment right plays into this argument is that as long as you comply with the property owners wishes you will not be arrested or charged with a crime. If you don't comply you will be charged with criminal trespass, which has nothing to do with your 1st Amendment right. It is my understanding that the city of Murfreesboro also has a city ordinance against this type of clothing. If someone complains on you the police could make you remove it. As far as someone wearing a controversial tee shirt that has a Confederate flag on it or has something like I hate Jesus, or I hate Mohammad, you are allowed to wear it as long as it does not cause a problem. For example causing an argument, violence or disruption. 

 The recent controversy over kneeling during the National Anthem is another good example. The NFL had every right to demand that their players be on the field and show the proper respect during the playing or singing of the National Anthem. The NFL is a business. Due to political correctness and the NFL's unwillingness to take a firm stand their business suffered. I don't know if they will ever be able to recoup their fan base to what it was prior to the kneeling episode in the NFL. As a veteran I am no longer an NFL fan for that reason. It would be the same thing if I chose to wear a controversial patch on my uniform such as a Confederate flag, a Black Lives Matters patch, or a peace symbol. My employer would have the right to tell me to remove it or I would face the disciplinary procedures. 

As far as my Facebook page I will never censor you for an opinion. Only for language which is also my 1st Amendment right. If Facebook is okay with you speaking that way then more power to you. I am not okay with it. It is my view that the Founding Fathers were not okay with it either. At this point I don't know that I could prove that by their writings but I think the 1st Amendment is directed primarily at political speech and political speech only. I do not believe that they meant to include foul language or pornography. The courts have broadened the meaning of the 1st Amendment to protect pornography but I don't recall a case that includes foul language. If you know of one please enlighten me. I have never agreed with their decision to cover pornography as free speech. The courts were never given the right of judicial review in the Constitution. John Marshall usurped that right in Marbury vs Madison,1803. 

 Should there no restrictions on free speech? Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes stated that a person should not have the right to shout fire in a crowded theater. I would expand that by asking the question, should our children be forced to learn foul language in our schools or to view pornography? Should there not be age restrictions? This question should also apply to drug use, or prostitution if these things were legalized., If you extend your arm and your fist does not reach my nose I am okay. But if you extend your arm and break my nose you have violated my rights. Under my 1st Amendment rights why should I be forced to read or listen to your foul language. Nobody is forcing me to go to your Facebook page if I don't want to.just like nobody is forcing me to walk into Spencers and buy a tee shirt with profanity on it. You choose a world where that kind of language is common. I choose a different world. Besides, I have many friends who are professed Christians and I want them to feel welcome on my page. As the old adage goes I disagree with what you say but I will defend to the death your right to say it. As long as you keep it clean.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

THE DEATH OF JAYNE MANSFIELD

-
Image
Jayne Mansfield   Jayne Mansfield died way too young on June 29, 1967 at the age of 34 in a gruesome car wreck, She was killed instantly but contrary to urban legend she was not decapitated. Jayne was called the poor man's Marilyn Monroe. She had enjoyed about a four year stint of popularity on Broadway and in Hollywood from 1954 until 1958. Her career was in decline in the late 50's and early 60's but she was still popular in Europe and on the nightclub circuit. She took her last name from her high school sweetheart Paul Mansfield when she married him at the age of seventeen. Her second husband was a former Mr. Universe named Mickey Hargitay who was from Norway. The third and last husband was Matt Cimber. Mansfield was highly educated, attending Southern Methodist University, the University of Texas and U.C.L.A. She supposedly had an IQ of 163 and was called the smartest dumb blonde ever. Of course she couldn't be too smart. In 1966, a year before her death, while...
Read more

CARNTON PLANTATION

-
Image
   My first association with the Carnton Plantation in Franklin was when I would see the old house while hunting for Civil War relics in the early 1970's. There is a subdivision near Carnton today in the area where I hunted when it was primarily farm land. I knew it was an antebellum home but I wasn't aware of how historic Carnton was. It was in a horrible state of disrepair and I have learned since then that a farmer was using the house as his hay barn. In 1977 the owner of the property donated the house and ten acres to the Carnton Association and they have done a fantastic job of restoring the plantation to it's former glory. Originally the McGavock's owned 1400 acres. It was built by Randall McGavock in the 1820's. He was mayor of Nashville and a close friend of Andrew Jackson and James K. Polk. Jackson on several occasions was an overnight guest in the home.    His son John took over the plantation in 1843 upon the death of Randall. In 1848 John mar...
Read more

NASHVILLE AND JESSE JAMES

-
Image
The James brothers with their mother Zerelda James   Most everyone has heard of the notorious outlaws Jesse and Frank James, however; did you know that they lived in Nashville from 1875 until March 1881? Jesse's oldest son Jesse James Jr. was born in Nashville along with his sister Mary. Jesse Jr. was born at 606 Boscobel Street on August 31, 1875. Mary was born on West Hamilton Road in Bordeaux on July 17, 1879. Jesse Jr. went by the name Tim and as far as he knew his last name was Howard. He and his sister would not know their real last names until after Jesse was killed in 1882. Jesse and his wife Zerelda would also lose two male twins in infancy.  Jesse's brother Frank lived on Clarksville Pike. While living there he and his wife Annie Ralston James gave birth to a son named Robert Franklin on February 6, 1877. For a time he would be dressed as a girl and go by the name of Mary. Why his parents did this I do not know.  The brothers were on the run. Nashvill...
Read more